Skylight leaking after a storm? How to tell whether it needs resealing, reflashing or replacing

If a skylight that's always stayed dry starts dripping after a hard Texas storm, there's usually a specific problem you can find. Sometimes it's the skylight itself. Often it's the metal and sealant that join the skylight to the roof. And now and then it isn't a leak at all.

If water's coming in right now, start with our guide to a roof leaking during a storm for the bucket, the breaker and the photos. Come back here once the rain stops.


First, make sure it's a leak

Check this before anything else, because the fix for condensation is completely different.

When warm, humid air touches cool glass, it turns to water on the glass. One skylight manufacturer's support page names condensation as a possible cause when a skylight looks like it's leaking. The water runs down the glazing, gathers on the frame and drips. From below, that looks a lot like rain getting in.

It's probably condensation if:

  • the water shows up on cool mornings or when the AC's running hard, with no rain involved
  • the inside of the glass is fogged or beaded all over, not wet at one edge or corner
  • the skylight is over a bathroom, a kitchen or a laundry room
  • the drywall around the skylight shaft is dry, and the water is on the glass and the frame

It's probably a leak if:

  • it only drips during or right after rain, and it's worst when the wind blows from a certain direction
  • the stain is on the drywall of the shaft or the ceiling next to it, often at an upper corner
  • the wood or drywall at the top of the shaft is soft, or darker than the rest

If it looks like condensation, do what the EPA advises: dry the wet surface quickly and cut the moisture at its source. Running the bathroom fan when you shower is one way. If you've got a venting skylight, make sure it's fully closed, too. That's the first thing on the same manufacturer's checklist.

There's a third possibility. Water can get into the roof uphill of the skylight, run down the roof deck and come out at the skylight opening, because that's the first gap it finds. Our post on water stains on the ceiling shows how water travels before it drips. So a roofer checks the area above a skylight before blaming the skylight.


What a storm does to a skylight

A skylight is glazing held in a frame, set into a hole cut through your roof. What keeps the rain out is the flashing: metal pieces that lap under and over the roofing around the frame, so water gets steered past the opening. The residential building code requires flashing "around roof openings."

Storms go after that joint in a few ways.

Wind is one. Ordinary rain runs down the roof and over the flashing. Rain pushed sideways by strong wind is different. It can be forced under a flashing edge that's lifted or bent, or through sealant that's dried out and cracked. That's why many skylights only leak in storms from a certain direction.

Hail is another. An insurer's hail guide, hosted on the website of the Texas State Office of Risk Management, lists skylights among the roof equipment hail can badly damage. Hail can crack glass or a plastic dome and dent the flashing. It can also knock granules off the shingles around the frame, which leaves that roofing more exposed.

Then there's debris. Branches and blown debris can crack glazing or bend flashing. They can also pile up on the uphill side of the skylight, where they hold water against the joint.

And there's age. Sealant and gaskets dry out and shrink as they age under the Texas sun. Often a storm just finds a weakness that was already there.


Reseal, reflash or replace

From the ground, every skylight leak looks the same: water inside. Up close, the cause points to the repair.

Resealing is the smallest of the three jobs. It can be the right repair when the flashing is sound, lies flat and is lapped correctly, and the leak traces back to sealant that's cracked or pulled away at the frame.

The catch is that sealant is a backup to the flashing. A roofer who smears caulk over a flashing problem may stop the drip for a while. But caulk on top of lifted or badly lapped flashing can also hold water in. If you see layers of old caulk around your skylight, that usually means the real problem was never fixed.

Reflashing means taking up the roofing around the skylight, removing the old flashing and putting in new flashing that laps correctly with the shingles. It fits when the glazing and frame are still in good condition and the trouble is around them. Maybe the flashing is bent or dented, rusted, or lifting at the edges. Maybe the skylight was flashed with improvised pieces or sealant where a proper flashing kit should be. Or the shingles around it were damaged and have to be replaced anyway. Done properly, new flashing deals with the joint itself, without replacing a skylight that has nothing wrong with it.

Replacing the skylight makes sense when the skylight is the problem:

  • the glass or dome is cracked or broken
  • a plastic dome has gone cloudy, or turned brittle and crazed
  • the frame is warped, or the wood of the curb under it has rotted
  • it's an older unit that's been patched before, and it's leaking again

Replacement also comes up when the whole roof is being replaced. Taking off the old roof disturbs the skylight and its flashing, and the roofing around it has to come off anyway. One skylight manufacturer's guidance for contractors goes further and says the best time to replace a skylight is when you re-roof, even before it leaks. Keep in mind that the company saying so sells skylights. Our guide to the best time to replace a roof in Dallas-Fort Worth covers planning the bigger job.

If hail's a regular worry where you live, ask about skylight guards or screens. The same insurer's guide lists protective screens over skylights as an option.


What you can check yourself

You can learn a lot without climbing on the roof:

  • From the ground, with binoculars if you have them, look for cracked glazing, missing or bent metal, and debris piled on the uphill side.
  • Inside, note where the water shows up: on the glass, at a corner of the frame, or on the shaft drywall. Take photos, and write down the date and which way the wind was blowing during the storm.
  • In the attic, if you can reach the skylight shaft, look for wet or dark wood around the framing.

Stay off a wet roof, and stay off the roof entirely during or right after a storm. A skylight also isn't something to stand near or lean on.


How we handle a leaking skylight

At Fit Roofing & Construction, we install, replace, repair and reseal skylights across Dallas-Fort Worth. It starts with a roof assessment: we identify the issues and give you detailed recommendations. Depending on what we find, that can mean resealing, new flashing, or a new skylight when the unit has failed.

Our skylight work also covers leak prevention and waterproofing around the opening, and ventilation improvements. Before any work starts, you get a proposal with material options, a timeline and pricing, and we answer your questions first.

If your skylight has started leaking after a storm, or you're not sure whether it's a leak or condensation, ask us to inspect your skylight and we'll tell you what we find.

Need Help With Your Roof?

Roofing tips and guides to help Texas homeowners make smarter decisions and avoid costly repairs.